Dear friends,
I’m not going to pretend to know a lot about politics. I don’t. A large part of that reason is that I generally try to avoid confrontation, and a good many confrontations start because of politics.
I’m also not going to pretend to know a lot about budgeting. I can barely manage my own budget (although I am getting much better at it!), so I’m not going to pretend that managing the budget of an entity as large as a state is an easy task. It’s not, and I don’t envy the people who have to do it.
I fully acknowledge that balancing a state budget when there is not enough money for everything is going to create anger, frustration, and enemies.
Since so far you know that I don’t know a lot, here is what I do know:
I am a teacher at an alternative school in which the teachers do not truly belong to a union. Our pension plans are managed by some sort of union, but I have to admit that I know less about that than I really should. As a small group of teachers, though, we do not collectively bargain for salaries and health care benefits.
I know that if I worked at a Chicago public school instead of an alternative school, I would be paid a lot more (we’re talking almost $10,000 more). I would also belong to a union, and my health care would be better than I have now. The union would take care of my concerns relating to my pension plan and health care, and I would be grateful for that.
I work where I work for a variety of reasons, which I will not discuss right now. What I do want to discuss is the possibility of a state making sweeping cuts that affect people like me. Thankfully Illinois has not had to deal with this particular issue (yet).
In Wisconsin, there are many more Republicans in the state legislature than Democrats. The governor, Scott Walker, wants to balance his state’s budget, and in order to do that, cuts must be made. Several of the proposed cuts will directly affect not only teachers but all state workers. Pensions will be cut, health care will be cut, and the right to collectively bargain will be cut.
My very basic understanding of the situation is this: if the proposed cuts are passed, state workers will still have to work. Teachers will still have to teach. Social workers will still have to meet the needs of their clientele. Sanitation workers will still have to cart away the trash. The biggest change will be in the ways they are compensated.
My dad is a pretty staunch republican. For years, I have listened to him talk about teachers and how much they make in their salaries PLUS their stellar health care and pension plans. I have understood and even agreed that teachers can get some pretty sweet deals.
Then I started teaching, albeit in the state of Illinois. And I disagree with my dad. On the surface, we get some pretty sweet deals. Summers off? Yes, please! Work on the clock: 6.5-7 hours? Yes, please!
But the sacrifices we have to make are much greater than many people realize. Many of us have had to take out large student loans in order to become certified to teach other peoples’ children. Many of us live paycheck to paycheck. Many of us purchase our students’ school supplies and classroom supplies because no one else will pay for them. Many of us stay up past our bedtimes to finish assessing our students’ progress and planning meaningful activities for our students. Many of us have to creatively balance our own budgets in order to pay for childcare OR rearrange our schedules to work around caring for our own children because we do not qualify for state-sponsored childcare programs. Many of us have to unfairly balance time between work and family time (hence staying up past bedtime to finish grading, etc.). Many of us wake in the freakishly wee hours of the morning in order to finish our work and prepare for the day ahead. Many of us are physically and emotionally exhausted by the end of the day. And then we have to get up and do it again.
Some of us who work with students who have failed out of “regular” schools also deal with the following: being emotionally abused and shattered (have you ever listened to a teenager tell you how she has to prostitute herself to feed her children?), being verbally assaulted, crying with and for our students, feeding our students with food paid for out of our own pockets, and much, much more.
I’m not going to make the money argument, because I’m bad at math. I get paid what I get paid, and between my husband and myself, we make it work. What I can say is that my salary was frozen this year and will likely be frozen again next year. I will be lucky if it isn’t cut. I will be lucky if my health care stays the same. And I work for a non-unionized school.
My friends in Wisconsin who do work where unions are present should have it better than me. Instead, they have taken pay cuts, furlough days, health care cuts, and pension cuts. They are being asked to give even more–no, they are being mandated to give more. If this bill that Governor Walker sponsors is passed, my friends will be forced to give up more AND not be able to collectively bargain for themselves in the future.
I don’t know how to fix the budget problems, but this doesn’t seem like the best way to do it.
A complicated issue requires a complicated solution, doesn’t it? And the commercials demonizing state union workers just makes everyone angry: the people it targets and the people it preaches to.
At the very least, I ask you to educate yourself about the situation in Wisconsin, because whether you live there or not, if this bill is passed, it will likely affect you sooner or later. Illinois is in even worse financial condition than Wisconsin, so this will likely be knocking on our doors next.
Again, the disclaimer: I did the best I could. I’m really sorry if I misconstrued the facts; I will be happy to discuss them with you. And while I think it is crass to proclaim that “Madison is the next Cairo,” I do think that we should seriously think about the implications of taking rights away in this democratic society.